OneSDR is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support our research and writing.
The development of radio frequency (RF) tools has made advanced signal analysis and software-defined radio (SDR) more accessible.
Two popular devices in this field are the TinySA Ultra spectrum analyzer and the HackRF One SDR transceiver.
🏷️ TinySA (with Discount Coupon) ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Both cover similar frequency ranges, but they are designed for different purposes. This article compares their features, strengths, weaknesses, and best uses, helping you understand which one suits your needs.
Table of Contents
Technical Comparison
| Feature | TinySA Ultra | HackRF One |
|---|---|---|
| Frequency Range | 100 kHz – 6 GHz (with harmonic mode up to 10 GHz) | 1 MHz – 6 GHz |
| Transmit Capability | No | Yes (half-duplex) |
| Max Bandwidth | 6 GHz sweep (Ultra mode) | 20 MHz instantaneous |
| Resolution | 70 dB dynamic range (LNA enabled) | 8-bit ADC |
| Display | 4″ built-in touchscreen | Requires external PC/smartphone |
| Portability | Standalone operation, 500 mAh battery | Requires host device; portable with add-ons (e.g., PortaPack) |
| Price | Check Price | Check Price |
| Signal Generator | Integrated (sine/square waves up to 4.4 GHz) | Software-dependent (via GNU Radio, SDR#) |
| Noise Floor | -153 dBm/Hz (LNA off), -169 dBm/Hz (LNA on) | -50 dBm typical (higher phase noise) |
Strengths and Limitations
TinySA Ultra
Pros:
- Specialized Spectrum Analysis: Optimized for rapid sweeps (165 ms for 0–350 MHz), with calibrated amplitude accuracy (±2 dB).
- Portability: Self-contained operation with a sunlight-readable display, ideal for field measurements like antenna tuning.
- Cost-Effective: Priced at 40% of the HackRF, it offers professional-grade analysis at hobbyist budgets.
- Low Noise Performance: Integrated LNA and step attenuator enable precise measurements down to -169 dBm/Hz.
Cons:
- No Transmission: Purely a receiver, limiting protocol experimentation.
- Limited Instantaneous Bandwidth: 640 kHz resolution filter restricts real-time wideband analysis.
HackRF One
Pros:
- Versatile SDR Platform: Full transceiver supporting custom signal modulation/demodulation (e.g., LoRa, Zigbee).
- Wideband Capture: 20 MHz instantaneous bandwidth enables real-time signal recording.
- Expandability: Compatible with PortaPack H2+ for standalone operation and advanced applications like GPS spoofing.
Cons:
- Complex Setup: Requires software expertise (e.g., GNURadio, SDRangel) for advanced tasks.
- Higher Noise Floor: 8-bit ADC limits dynamic range, producing spurious signals above -35 dBc.
Typical Applications
TinySA Ultra
- RF Compliance Testing: Detecting harmonics in commercial radios (e.g., Baofeng UV-5R spurs at 270 MHz).
- Antenna Characterization: Measuring VSWR and radiation patterns using tracking generator mode.
- Educational Use: Visualizing WiFi channel occupancy and signal leakage in 2.4/5 GHz bands.
HackRF One
- Wireless Security Research: Analyzing IoT protocols (Zigbee, LoRaWAN) for vulnerabilities.
- Signal Intelligence: Capturing ADS-B aircraft signals (1090 MHz) or AIS marine traffic data.
- Custom Modulation: Implementing novel waveforms for academic or ham radio projects.
Conclusion
The TinySA Ultra excels as a dedicated spectrum analyzer, offering calibrated accuracy and portability for field technicians and educators. Its standalone operation and low noise floor make it indispensable for antenna tuning and regulatory compliance checks.
Conversely, the HackRF One thrives in experimental SDR applications, where transmission capability and software flexibility outweigh its noise limitations.
For hobbyists prioritizing signal analysis, the TinySA Ultra’s affordability and simplicity are unmatched. Developers and researchers requiring bidirectional RF interaction, however, will find the HackRF’s versatility justifies its steeper learning curve.
Ultimately, pairing both devices creates a powerful toolkit, combining the TinySA’s measurement precision with the HackRF’s programmable agility.
